You sunk my methodology!

Agile Games – Battleships

No plan of operations extends with certainty beyond the first encounter with the enemy’s main strength – Generalfeldmarschall Helmuth von Moltke

 

 

This is a game I use to introduce people to iterative development. The aim is to help the players to understand that upfront large plans are pointless the minute they are created. Helmuth (quoted above), for me, was one of the first proponents of an iterative approach. He didn’t necessarily create grand plans, conversely he didn’t disregard planning altogether, but he was smart enough to plan just enough and adjust his plan to meet the changing reality. Often my experience of working on projects with large up front plans, the opposite is true and the owner of that plan tries to adjust the reality to fit the plan.

So how do you play it?

Simple, one player (Player A) is given 40-45 pegs and told to place their ships and all their planned attacks up front. The second player (Player B) simultaneously places their ships. Once that has been done, the first player reads out the 40 pre-planned attacks and is given the hits and misses. Player B then get to play each attack (up to 40-45) separately, getting feedback on hits & misses for each.

It’s pretty obvious what will happen, most of the time Player B’s turn (iterative) based play will allow him to adjust and change his plans as he scores hits. Player A (large plan) will score hits, but is far less likely to sink all the opponents ships. So player B being limited to 40 moves also may sink the whole fleet or not, typically though that player will score more hits than the other.

What does this tell us?

Predictive planning is unreliable and is akin to reading crystal balls, reading tea leaves or any other clairvoyant technique you care to mention. Ultimately you’re predicting the future based on an infinite number of possible outcomes, effects and variables. The iterative approach is empirical, each time Player B hits his opponents ships, he can instantly change plans and target nearby locations to sink it.

There are a few other parallels you can draw from it.. Player A will often score hits but not sink, this is akin to features that were developed but not tested before time or money ran out. Player B however may not hit all the ships but is much more likely to sink the ones he does hit, making it a metaphor for “potentially shippable product increments” (no pun intended).

Occasionally Player A wins, this is a bit like the fortune teller coincidentally getting something right, it’s often more luck than judgement.

All games and techniques on HurricaneFour.com are licenced under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported Licence. If you use them in a public place, please credit the source.

Tags: , , , , , , ,

7 Responses to “You sunk my methodology!”

  1. Mark Suurmond April 1, 2012 at 20:24 #

    Hi,

    A few colleages and me made a javascript version for this game. You can download it here: http://blog.zilverline.com/2012/04/01/the-power-of-feedback-in-scrum/

    Thanks for the idea!

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Week 7 | Agility | 25.10.2016 – Digital Design and Development - December 4, 2016

    […] week’s blog post I googled “Battleship game iterative planning” and read some blogs focusing on subjects around agile development and saw that this game is actually used quite […]

  2. Agile Project Management and a Naval Bombardment in Newport, South Wales | What's the PONT - December 2, 2012

    […] round good guy (and web strategy gun-slinger) Joel Hughes. The methodology for what we did can be found here on James’ site, and here is a link to James’ slides. This is what I took from a very illuminating exercise, […]

  3. You sunk my methodology « TastyCupcakes.org - February 1, 2012

    […] You Sunk My Methodology VN:F [1.9.11_1134]Rate Thisplease wait…Rating: 4.0/5 (1 vote cast)You sunk my methodology, 4.0 out of 5 based on 1 rating Written by: James Scrimshire on February 1, 2012. No comments currently exist for this post. Leave a Reply: Click here to cancel reply. […]

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: